Installing ground-mounted solar panels vs. roof-mounted solar panels offers distinct advantages and challenges. It depends on many things, such as available space, aesthetics, energy efficiency, and maintenance. How do you decide? Look at your property needs. Understand local environmental conditions. Then, compare this to your project goals.
I hope the outline below helps. It compares the differences between both types of installations. Choose the one that works best for you.
Space and Location Requirements
- Rooftop Solar Panels:
-
- Benefits of Unused Space: Rooftop solar panels use otherwise underutilized space, making them an excellent option for urban or suburban areas where land is scarce or expensive.
-
- Roof Size Limits: Less rooftop space means a smaller solar array. Large rooftops offer more space for solar panels. Before starting a roof-mounted project, confirm that the available space will meet your energy needs.
- Ground-Mounted Solar Panels:
-
- More Space: There is much more ground to work with than rooftop space. You can install them in open fields or large yards, making them ideal for rural or large properties with ample land.
-
- Not Limited by Roof Size: You can scale the system according to available land, allowing for more solar panels and greater energy production, especially in commercial or agricultural applications.
Orientation and Tilt Adjustability
- Rooftop Solar Panels:
-
- Roof Orientation Dependency: How much energy gets generated and how evenly it gets generated depends on your rooftop. It is all about the rooftop orientation and pitch. In the Northern Hemisphere, a south-facing roof at a suitable angle maximizes energy production. However, suppose the roof is not ideally positioned or shaded by nearby structures or trees. In that case, you may see less solar output.
-
- Limited Adjustability: Rooftop solar panels are generally fixed in place. As the seasons change, the angle of the sun changes with it. Adjusting solar roof panels to maximize energy is not that easy.
- Ground-Mounted Solar Panels:
-
- Easy to Adjust: Move the panels to get the best sun exposure. Installers can orient and tilt the panels to achieve the best possible angle to capture sunlight throughout the day and across seasons.
-
- Adjustable Tilt: Use a ground-mounted system with manual or automatic tilt adjustments. The sun’s angle changes over time, so align panels to the sun for more energy production.
Installation Costs
- Rooftop Solar Panels:
-
- Lower Installation Costs: Since roof-mounted solar panels utilize existing infrastructure (the roof), there is typically no need to prepare the ground, pour concrete foundations, or install support structures. You benefit from lower initial installation costs.
-
- Potential Roof Reinforcements: Roofs must be structurally sound enough to support solar panels. How sturdy is your roof? How old is your roof? Is your answer “not too sturdy” or “fairly old” plan on roof reinforcements or repairs? That adds to the total project cost.
- Ground-Mounted Solar Panels:
-
- Higher Installation Costs: Ground-mounted systems often require additional materials such as mounting racks, poles, or concrete foundations, which increases overall cost. Does land need to be cleared or leveled before installation? If it does, your project costs go up.
-
- Fewer Structural Considerations: Ground-mounted panels do not depend on a building’s structural integrity, making them easier to install for properties with weaker or older roofs.
Energy Efficiency and Performance
- Rooftop Solar Panels:
-
- Prone to Overheating: Solar panels on a roof can experience overheating due to a lack of airflow underneath, which can reduce their efficiency. However, many rooftop systems include space between the roof and the panels to improve ventilation.
-
- Limited by Shading: Trees, nearby buildings, or roof features like chimneys can cast shadows over rooftop panels, reducing efficiency. Once installed, panels are pretty much set in place. They cannot be easily adjusted to point away from the shading.
- Ground-Mounted Solar Panels:
-
- Better Cooling: Ground-mounted systems tend to have more airflow underneath the panels, allowing them to operate at lower temperatures. You benefit from higher efficiency, especially in hot climates.
-
- Less Shading: Looking to get the most out of the sunlight? Install ground-mounted panels in open areas. Look at buildings and trees. Line up how the shade will change over time. Install panels away from as much shadow and shade as possible.
Maintenance and Accessibility
- Rooftop Solar Panels:
-
- Less Accessible: Due to limited access, maintaining, cleaning, or repairing rooftop panels can be more complex and time-consuming. Installers may need specialized equipment to reach the panels safely.
-
- Exposure to Roof Hazards: Rooftop panels are exposed to more wear and tear from roof conditions, including leaks or structural damage, which can affect solar panel installation integrity.
- Ground-Mounted Solar Panels:
-
- Easier Maintenance: Ground-mounted systems are, after all, on the ground, which makes them easier to access. Routine maintenance and cleaning are more convenient. You can quickly inspect or repair panels without needing special equipment.
-
- Vulnerable to Physical Damage: Ground-mounted systems are exposed to physical damage. Falling debris, wind-blown objects, wildlife, and accidental impacts are all problems. Proper fencing or barriers may be necessary to protect the panels.
Aesthetic and Zoning Considerations
- Rooftop Solar Panels:
-
- Blends With Existing Structure: Rooftop solar panels are less visually intrusive and blend with the building’s architecture. After all, curb appeal is everything and panels that blend in offer better aesthetics and curb appeal.
-
- Zoning and HOA Restrictions: Do you live in an HOA? Do you have a designated historic home? Some homeowner associations (HOAs) or local zoning laws restrict rooftop installations. This is particularly true in historic districts or visually sensitive areas.
- Ground-Mounted Solar Panels:
-
- More Visually Prominent: Solar panels on the ground are often more visible. After all, they are on eye level and take up a lot of land, both of which may not be desirable for aesthetic reasons in residential settings.
-
- More Zoning Restrictions: Ground-mounted systems may face stricter zoning regulations, including setback requirements or limits on land use. These restrictions affect where and how panels are installed.
Longevity and Roof Impact
- Rooftop Solar Panels:
-
- Dependent on Roof Life: When will your roof need to be repaired? The roof’s lifespan may limit the lifespan of rooftop solar panels. If the roof needs replacing, the panels get removed and reinstalled, which adds costs.
-
- Potential Roof Damage: Improper panel installation can damage the roof, and extreme weather can damage it, leading to problems such as leaks. Every homeowner wants to avoid these issues. Qualified professionals who install solar panels correctly can reduce this risk.
- Ground-Mounted Solar Panels:
-
- No Roof Impact: Ground-mounted panels do not affect the lifespan of the roof, which can be a major advantage for properties with older roofs. Independent of any structure, the panels can last their full expected lifespan (typically 25-30 years) without roof-related concerns.
Ground-Mounted Solar Panels vs Roof-Mounted
Rooftop and ground-mounted solar panels each have unique advantages and drawbacks.
- Rooftop systems are ideal for properties with limited space. Enjoy lower installation costs. Benefit from minimal visual impact.
- Ground-mounted systems offer better energy efficiency, ease of maintenance, and greater flexibility in system size and placement, making them an excellent choice for properties with ample land.
Which is best for you? It’s about the details. What are your available space, budget, and aesthetic preferences? Don’t forget to identify your energy production goals. Outline your needs first, then select the system that is best for you.